Insecure architect Peter (Jason Ritter) and art gallery employee Vandy (Jess Weixler) fall for each other and quickly fall into a serious relationship with one another. As their relationship grows, and begins to turn into a somewhat twisted and manipulative relationship, the two begin to look back to events in the past of their relationship as a way of trying to determine what happened and how they became the way they are today. Through this time of looking back, they ask themselves the hows and whys of the development of their relationship, and try to determine how they got the way they are now.