Art and life do not always imitate each other. Such is the case for art curator Beth (Kristen Bell), a beautiful woman who has no luck in love. When she meets Nick (Josh Duhamel), who is smitten with her, she dismisses him too. In an effort to find the right man, she reverses the coins in the fountain concept by taking five coins out of the water. She is then magically followed from Rome to New York by the men who threw the coins into the Fountain of Love, looking for romance. The result is not much better. Suitors show up at her New York City residence, and not one is to her liking, much to the chagrin of her father (Don Johnson). Her boss at the Guggenheim, Celeste (Anjelica Huston), is not any help.