After discovering that a sorority sister's boyfriend cheated on her, sister house Theta Pi decides to play a prank on the boyfriend, making him think he killed his girlfriend. They take the prank even further, taking him into the middle of nowhere to "dismember" the body, only to finally reveal the prank. However, things go terribly wrong, and everyone involved vows to never speak of the incident again. A year later at graduation, however, they are reminded of that terrible event. What happened out in the middle of nowhere, and will the people involved ever be able to forget it happened?