The Tooth Fairy (Tom Noonan) is visiting homes at night. But instead of taking teeth, this fairy is taking lives. But when no one can catch the killer, the FBI Agent Jack Crawford (Dennis Farina) seeks out Will Graham (William Petersen). Only Graham, a former FBI agent, is retired, burned out, and almost psychotic. Petersen was responsible for the capture of another serial killer, the infamous cannibal, Hannibal Lecter. But in order to catch him, the FBI agent had gotten inside the killer's head. And he almost didn't get out. He got his man but he almost lost his mind. Now, it seems that Petersen must risk his sanity again.